Energy Research Switzerland

Producing wind power when there is a lull elsewhere

Large-scale weather conditions determine wind power production in Europe. In Switzerland, however, wind conditions are also strongly influenced by complex local topographies. Researchers investigated the question of which regions in Switzerland have anti-cyclical production patterns as a result. This could be an incentive to invest in wind power.
Complex wind conditions as an opportunity

A wind turbine in Collonges near Martigny: on the Rhone Bend, the wind blows significantly stronger than in surrounding countries in certain large-scale weather conditions. Source: Suisse Eole

At a glance

Due to the complex topography, there are areas in Switzerland where wind conditions behave differently than in surrounding regions. In different European weather conditions, which can last from days to weeks, the winds at some locations in Switzerland behave in the opposite way to those in neighbouring countries. This anti-correlation can make the use of wind power interesting in certain regions, even if the average wind speed is not very high.

Today, wind turbines are mainly built in the flat north of Europe. Because large-scale weather phenomena often influence the wind conditions there, their electricity production follows a similar temporal pattern. Consequently, large fluctuations in the wind power supply are to be expected. In hilly regions, on the other hand, the large-scale European weather situation is overlaid by small-scale weather phenomena. This is why the wind often blows there when there is calm in other regions of Europe - and vice versa. Could this variability be exploited in a targeted way to balance wind power production across Europe? Researchers at ETH Zurich have investigated this question with model calculations. They have modelled the wind conditions in various regions of Switzerland and neighbouring Europe and analysed the effect of seven major weather situations in the past.

Striking regional variability

Various phenomena influence the wind conditions at a location. Typically, wind speeds in valleys increase in the afternoon, while they are highest at night on ridges. As expected, the modelling showed such diurnal fluctuations in the upper Rhine valley, on the Rhone bend in the Valais and in the Vedeggio valley. However, large-scale weather situations can also lead to typical wind conditions in Switzerland due to the topography. For example, when there is high air pressure north of Switzerland, the wind channels itself between the Alpine chain and the Jura to form an iron flow as far as Lake Geneva. With their modelling, the researchers investigated at which locations such regional effects lead to wind conditions that differ significantly from the surrounding countries. They found that during high-pressure-dominated weather conditions, the wind blows significantly stronger at Lake Geneva and at the Rhone Bend in Valais. The Vedeggio valley in Ticino also shows above-average wind performance in certain weather conditions.

Anti-correlation as an incentive

These regions could therefore produce wind power when the rotors in other regions are at a standstill. The authors of the study see this as an incentive for the construction of new wind turbines, even if the average wind speed does not suggest this at first glance. However, they are hardly able to make a contribution to smoothing the European wind power production. Because these regions are far too small in comparison.

In the Jura, on the other hand, wind conditions correlate with those in the rest of Europe. However, because this region has the highest average wind speeds in all of Switzerland, the wind farms there are already economically viable today.

Products from the project

Final report: Spatial-temporal variability of wind energy potential in Switzerland and neighbouring  countries

Contact and team

Project management

Stefan Pfenninger

ETHZ Institut für Atmosphäre und Klima

Universitätstrasse 16

CH-8092 Zürich

stefan.pfenninger@usys.ethz.ch

TU Delft, Faculty of Technology, Policy and Management

+31 15 27 86 336

S.Pfenninger@tudelft.nl